Vintage weapons are surviving items from the original Murder Mystery game that were carried into Murder Mystery 2. Only nine standard Vintage weapons remain in this category, so their prices are driven mainly by fixed supply, age, nostalgia, and collector demand rather than current crate availability. When comparing fixed-supply collectibles, review the Ancient values and Godly values lists alongside these items.
Compare the values below before trading Ghost, Blood, America, Prince, Shadow, Phaser, Cowboy, Golden, or Splitter. Vintage demand is usually lower than top Godly or Ancient demand, so a fair numerical offer may still take longer to complete.
Last reviewed: August 21, 2026.
Vintage Items
Values last updated
MM2 Vintage Values FAQ
What makes a weapon Vintage in MM2?
Vintage weapons are surviving items from the original Murder Mystery game that were carried into Murder Mystery 2. They are not current box or event rewards, and the standard Vintage category contains only nine weapons. Their MM1 origin, fixed supply and age distinguish them from modern Godly, Ancient and other MM2 rarity categories.
Are Vintage items rarer than Godly items?
Vintage weapons have a limited old supply, but that does not mean every Vintage is worth more than every Godly. Trading value also depends on how many players currently want the item and how easily it can be exchanged. Compare each weapon with the current Godly values instead of treating the category name as a guaranteed ranking.
Why are some Vintage weapons difficult to trade?
Vintage items mainly appeal to collectors, and their active demand can be lower than the demand for popular event weapons or matching sets. This means a numerically fair Vintage offer may take longer to find a buyer. Traders sometimes accept a small underpay for a quicker trade, so demand should be checked before relying only on listed value.
Which matters more for Vintage items: value or demand?
Both matter. Listed value helps compare the size of an offer, while demand shows how likely other players are to accept that item later. A Vintage with modest value but steady demand can be easier to use than one with a slightly higher number and weak offers. Compare fixed-supply collectibles with relevant Ancient values before trading.