15 Rarest MM2 Items in 2026: Hardest to Get Ranked

The rarest item in Murder Mystery 2 is Nik’s Scythe: only seven exist in the entire game, and it can never be traded. But rarity and value are not the same thing in MM2. Some of the rarest items are priceless, some are surprisingly cheap, and one famous “rare” knife lost almost everything in a 2017 duping glitch. Here are the 15 hardest items to get, with the real story behind each.

Rarity is not value: read this first

A rare item has few copies. A valuable item has buyers. Bat proves the difference: it is a godly knife locked to the 2022 Halloween event (20th tier zombie rewards, 50,000 candies), so no new copies will ever exist, yet it trades cheaply with rarity and demand ratings of just 2 out of 10. Why? The event was well attended, so plenty of copies exist, and demand is modest. Scarcity without demand is just a curiosity. Keep that in mind as you read this list.

The untouchables: untradeable and leaderboard items

1. Nik’s Scythe. Seven exist, gifted by developer Nikilis to players who helped fix bugs. Untradeable. If someone offers you one, it is a scam, full stop.

2. Gold Gingerscythe. A gold trophy weapon from the 2023 Christmas gift-giving leaderboard. Trophy weapons go to a tiny number of top leaderboard players and almost never trade hands.

3. Gold Celestial. From the 2024 Christmas coin-collecting leaderboard. Same story: a handful of winners, effectively unobtainable for everyone else.

4. Gold Constellation. The 2024 Christmas gift-giving gold trophy. Leaderboard golds are the closest thing to Nik’s Scythe that ordinary players can name.

5. Silver and Bronze trophies. Each leaderboard also produced silver and bronze variants in similarly tiny numbers. They are the forgotten cousins of the golds, but just as hard to find.

The tradable legends

6. Chroma Traveler’s Gun (140,000, Stable). The most valuable tradeable item in MM2 and the rarest chroma, from the 2023 Halloween Box. Its price is the market’s way of saying almost nobody will sell.

7. Chroma Evergun (56,000). A distant second among chromas, and still worth more than nearly every non-chroma item in the game.

8. Traveler’s Axe (about 7,350). A limited ancient-tier item whose gamepass-era supply was small. It trades like a blue chip because owners rarely let go.

9. Gingerscope (15,500). The most valuable ancient weapon in October 2026, and flagged “Underpaid For” with demand 5, meaning buyers want it more than the list suggests. High value plus real demand equals genuinely hard to acquire.

10. Corrupt. The first unique weapon ever, given to victims of the 2014 Data Loss Glitch. It was once the second-rarest knife in the game with only around 63 owners, then the 2017 duping glitch flooded it to thousands of copies. It is the only tradable unique, a piece of MM2 history, and a warning that rarity can evaporate overnight.

Small supply, quiet demand

11. Vintage Ghost and 12. Vintage America. Vintage-tier weapons from MM2’s earliest days. Almost nobody trades them, and when they do, prices are modest, because the collector pool is tiny.

13. Snow Dagger. The godly knife from the 2025 Christmas Box at a 0.2% unbox chance. New enough that supply is still settling, rare enough that most players will never unbox one.

14. Chroma Snow Dagger. Under a 0.1% chance from the same box. One of the hardest unboxes in recent MM2 history.

15. Icebreaker. An older ancient from a past Christmas event with a small, aging supply. It rarely appears in trading servers, which is its own kind of rarity.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the rarest item in MM2?

Nik’s Scythe, with only seven in existence. It is untradeable, so the rarest item you can actually own is debatable, but nothing beats seven copies.

Is Corrupt still rare after the duping glitch?

Not really. It went from about 63 owners to thousands of copies after the 2017 duping glitch. It remains historically significant as the first unique weapon and the only tradable unique, but its rarity is gone.

Why are some rare items cheap?

Because value needs demand. Bat is event-locked forever yet trades cheaply, since the 2022 Halloween event gave out many copies and few collectors chase it. Always check both rarity and demand before paying a premium.

Can rarity change over time?

Yes, in both directions. Duping glitches destroy rarity overnight, as Corrupt proved. Slowly, banned accounts and inactive players remove copies from circulation, which is why fixed-supply items like chromas tend to creep upward.

Compare values on our full value list, browse the ancient tier page for the rarest weapon class, check chroma prices on the chroma page, and see top godlies on the godly page.