Best MM2 Pets in 2026: Top Values and Trading Picks

The most valuable MM2 pet in October 2026 is the Zombie Dog at 295, more than four times the value of the next-best pet. That gap matters, because most pets in Murder Mystery 2 are cheap cosmetics with weak demand, while a small handful trade like real currency. Below are the pets actually worth your attention, ranked by October 2026 Supreme Values with demand notes.

The top tier: Zombie Dog stands alone

Zombie Dog (295, demand 3) is the undisputed king of MM2 pets. It is the only pet that trades at godly-level values and holds its price across updates. If you own one, treat it like a high-tier weapon: never quicksell it, and expect buyers to need time to gather offers. Note that some lists use a different value scale where Zombie Dog shows as 725; that is the MM2Values scale, not Supreme. The ranking is the same either way, only the numbers differ.

The solid mid tier: event pets with real demand

Below Zombie Dog sits a cluster of Halloween and Christmas event pets that trade steadily:

Blue Pumpkin (65) and Purple Pumpkin (50) lead the Halloween pets, followed by Red Pumpkin (45), Green Pumpkin (30), and Black Cat (30). The pumpkins are the pet world’s blue chips: recognizable, seasonal, and always tradeable.

Jetstream (45, demand 3) and Overseer Eye (42) are strong non-seasonal picks, with Eyeball (40) and Santa Pet 2019 (40) close behind. Santa Pet 2019 benefits from its age; anything from 2019 or earlier carries collector interest. Dogey (35), Vampire Bat (32), Nobledragon (25), and Fairy (22) round out the tradeable middle.

These are the pets worth actively trading. They have enough value to matter in offers and enough demand that you can move them without waiting weeks.

The budget tier: chroma fire pets

The seven chroma pets, Chroma Fire Dog, Bear, Pig, Fox, Bat, Cat, and Bunny, are the cheapest chromas in the entire game. Chroma Fire Cat (20) and Chroma Fire Bunny (18) top the group, while Chroma Fire Bear (8) and Chroma Fire Pig (9) are the cheapest chroma items you can own. They are fun collectibles and cheap set-fillers, but do not expect them to grow: their demand is low and supply is plentiful. Their low prices also make them popular first trades for new players learning how the trade window works.

Which pets are worth trading for?

For value: Zombie Dog, then the pumpkin trio. These hold value and convert easily into weapons when you want out.

For flipping: mid-tier pets like Jetstream, Overseer Eye, and Santa Pet 2019 move at predictable prices, so patient traders can buy low and sell at list.

For collecting: the chroma fire pets are cheap and look great, but buy them to enjoy, not as investments.

Avoid: brand-new event pets during their event. Like event godlies, pet prices dip while everyone is earning them and recover later. Buy after the event, not during it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most valuable pet in MM2 in 2026?

Zombie Dog, at 295 on the Supreme scale in October 2026. The next closest pets, Blue Pumpkin at 65 and Purple Pumpkin at 50, are worth less than a quarter of it.

Are MM2 pets a good investment?

Mostly no. Only the top few pets hold value like weapons. The vast majority of pets are cheap cosmetics with low demand that are hard to resell. Treat pets as fun extras unless you are dealing in the top tier.

Why do different sites show different pet values?

Supreme Values and MM2Values use different scales. Zombie Dog is 295 on Supreme and 725 on the MM2Values scale. The relative ranking is the same; only the numbers change. Always compare values from the same source.

Can pets be unboxed or only traded?

Most valuable pets came from past events or boxes and are now trade-only. Current events occasionally add new pets, so check the active event before assuming a pet is unobtainable.

See every pet’s current number on our MM2 pets value page, compare against the full item value list, check weapon equivalents on the godly page, and study the weapon tier list before offering pets in trades.